Canada put "wrong" maple leaf on new Canadian dollar 20 bill: expert

Posted by Randall Palmer, REUTERS on 2/19/2013

According to a January 18 article in Reuters,The Bank of Canada has barked up the wrong maple tree with its new plastic banknotes, using a foreign Norway maple leaf as the emblem on the notes instead of the sugar maple that the country has on its national flag, an eagle-eyed Canadian botanist says.

The untrained eye might not at first spot the difference between the maple leaf on the new $20, $50 and $100 bills and the North American sugar maple.

But it is clear to Sean Blaney, a botanist who tracks plants for the Atlantic Canada Conservation Data Center in New Brunswick, and who brought it first to the attention of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.

"The maple leaf (on the currency) is the wrong species," he told Reuters on Friday.

He said the Norway maple has more lobes or sections and has a more pointed outline than the sugar maple, and the lobe that rises in the center is shorter than the sugar maple's.

The Norway maple was imported from Europe and is now also common in North America. Blaney said it was probably the most popular tree along streets in central and eastern Canada.

"It has naturalized to Canada," he said. But it's not the grand sugar maple.

The central bank said the image on the new bills was purposefully designed not to represent any specific species but rather to be a combination of various kinds.

"It is not a Norway maple leaf. It is a stylized maple leaf and it is what it ought to be," said Bank of Canada currency spokesman Julie Girard.

She said the banknote designers created the image with the help of a dendrologist, a botanist who specializes in trees and shrubs.

"On the advice of this expert, steps were taken to ensure that the design of the leaf in the secondary window is not representative of a Norway maple," she said, adding that it was less rectangular than a Norway maple.

Blaney is not buying the explanation. "I think it's just an after-the-fact excuse," he said.

"That may have been their intention, to not have it be a specific species of maple, but they should have drawn it differently if that were the case, because the maple that they've drawn is quite clearly a Norway maple."

The Bank of Canada had to apologize in August after news broke that it replaced the picture of an Asian lab assistant on its new C$100 banknote with a woman who looked more Caucasian.

Focus groups said Asians should not be the only group represented. Critics then accused the bank of racism.

(Editing by Janet Guttsman and Mohammad Zargham)

This is a guest article. The thoughts and opinions in this piece are those of their author and are not necessarily the thoughts of the Certified Collectibles Group.




    Contact Us
  • Headquarters
    PMG
    P.O. Box 4755
    Sarasota, FL 34230
  • Hong Kong
    NGC-NCS-PMG
    Tsim Sha Tsui, Kowloon
    Hong Kong
    +852 2115-3639
    Asia@PMGnotes.com
  • Switzerland
    NGC-NCS-PMG
    Zurich, CHE
    +41 79 265 7591
    Europe@PMGnotes.com
  • 1-877-PMG-5570 toll free
    +1 941-309-1001
    +1 941-309-1002 fax
    Service@PMGnotes.com
  • Germany
    NGC-NCS-PMG
    Konstanz, Germany
    +49 (0)7531 89 262 340
    Europe@PMGnotes.com
  • Official Grading Service of

© 2014 Paper Money Guaranty, LLC | Legal Notice and Usage Restrictions | 877-PMG-5570